The Reference Check Stage: The One Part of the Hiring Process You Can't Fake
Updated: 4 days ago
"The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place." - George Bernard Shaw
You have made it through the application process. Your CV has impressed the hiring manager, you've performed well in the interview, and now the employer asks for your referees.
Many candidates see this as a formality.
It isn't.
In many cases, the reference check stage is one of the most important steps in the entire recruitment process.
Why? Because at this point, the employer wants to hear from someone who has actually worked with you.
Your CV tells them what you've done.
Your interview tells them what you say you can do.
Your referee tells them what you're actually like to work with.
Why Employers Value Reference Checks
Hiring someone is a significant investment. Employers want to reduce risk as much as possible before making a final offer.
A referee can provide insights that don't always appear on a CV or come across in an interview.
Employers may ask questions about:
Work ethic
Reliability
Time management
Attendance and punctuality
Communication skills
Teamwork
Stress management
Leadership capability
Ability to meet deadlines
Areas for development
They aren't looking for perfection.
They're looking for a genuine understanding of how you perform in a real workplace environment.
The strongest referee is often someone who has directly managed your work and can confidently speak about your performance.
Don't Surprise Your Referees
One of the biggest mistakes candidates make is providing referee details without speaking to their referees first.
Imagine this scenario:
A hiring manager calls your former manager.
Your manager answers the phone and says:
"Oh, I didn't know they had applied for a role."
Immediately, it raises concerns.
Not because you've done anything wrong, but because it suggests a lack of communication and preparation.
A potential employer may start wondering:
Does this candidate communicate effectively?
Is this referee truly prepared to support them?
Will I receive an accurate and informed reference?
A strong reference check process begins before you submit a referee's details.
Choose Your Referees Carefully
Not all referees carry the same weight.
Whenever possible, select people who have directly observed your work and can provide meaningful feedback.
The best referees are usually:
Current or previous managers
Team leaders
Supervisors
Department managers
In some situations, a senior colleague may be appropriate, particularly if they worked closely with you on a daily basis.
Avoid choosing someone simply because they will say nice things.
Choose someone who can genuinely speak about your skills, performance, and contribution.
Prepare Your Referees
The moment a prospective employer asks for referee details, it's time to make contact.
Reach out to your chosen referees and let them know:
You've progressed in the recruitment process
The role you've applied for
The company involved
Why you're interested in the opportunity
The key skills being assessed
This helps your referee provide relevant and meaningful information when contacted.
The conversation can be as simple as:
"Hi Sarah, I've been shortlisted for a Project Manager position and they've requested references. Would you be comfortable acting as a referee? The hiring manager may contact you over the next week regarding my leadership, stakeholder management, and project experience."
A prepared referee is a confident referee.
Ask How They Prefer to Be Contacted
Not everyone likes receiving unexpected phone calls.
Some people prefer:
Phone calls
Emails
Scheduled conversations
Ask your referee what works best for them.
Then provide those details to the employer.
For example:
Sarah Smith
Programme Manager
Managed me from January 2022 to August 2025
Worked together for three and a half years
Preferred contact method: Phone
Contact Details: Phone number and email address
This demonstrates professionalism and organisation.
It also makes the employer's job easier.
Help Your Referee Help You
Your referee shouldn't be trying to remember details from three years ago without context.
A quick reminder of key projects, achievements, and responsibilities can be incredibly helpful.
This isn't about telling them what to say.
It's about helping them recall the work you did together so they can provide an accurate reflection of your performance
Follow Up Professionally
Once you've provided the referee details, stay in touch.
If your referee receives an email or phone call, thank them for taking the time to assist.
Reference checks can take longer than people realise, particularly when managers have busy schedules.
Showing appreciation goes a long way.
After all, your referees are taking time out of their day to support your career progression.
Don't Chase the Employer Too Quickly
Once your references have been completed, it's tempting to follow up immediately.
Try to be patient.
The employer may still need to:
Complete other interviews
Discuss candidates internally
Review feedback
Obtain approvals
Finalise salary discussions
Following up respectfully is perfectly acceptable, but giving the employer adequate time to complete their process demonstrates professionalism and good judgement.
Patience is part of the process.
A Reference Check Is More Than a Tick Box
Many candidates think the hard work is done once they've reached the reference stage.
In reality, this is often where final hiring decisions are influenced.
A strong referee can reinforce everything you've communicated throughout the recruitment process.
They can provide reassurance that you're reliable, capable, professional, and someone who will contribute positively to the team.
Just as importantly, they can demonstrate that you maintain strong working relationships long after you've left an organisation.
Final Thoughts
Reference checks are not simply an administrative exercise. They are an opportunity for someone else to vouch for your character, capability, and contribution.
The best candidates treat this stage with the same level of preparation as the interview itself.
Remember:
Your referees are part of your professional brand. The way you prepare and communicate with them tells a potential employer just as much about you as the reference itself.
Choose your referees carefully, keep them informed, respect their time, and maintain open communication throughout the process. A prepared referee can be the final piece that helps turn a promising application into a job offer.
By Amanda Dubier
Comments